#1 - 2017-5-20 08:12
Thunder (noblesse oblige)
可能有误伤,有话好说,别打我
之前vxow大大把举报楼真爱楼给删了,补一个好了
基本都是些新注册、只用过一两次、没头像、昵称莫名其妙或别有用心、标记条目较少、没点过标签、分数集中在1和10的ID
http://bgm.tv/user/328780
http://bgm.tv/user/329955
http://bgm.tv/user/330625
http://bgm.tv/user/331247
http://bgm.tv/user/331270
http://bgm.tv/user/331278
http://bgm.tv/user/331281
http://bgm.tv/user/331280
http://bgm.tv/user/331290
http://bgm.tv/user/331299
http://bgm.tv/user/331303
http://bgm.tv/user/331465
http://bgm.tv/user/331624
http://bgm.tv/user/332935
http://bgm.tv/user/331862
http://bgm.tv/user/331249
http://bgm.tv/user/331640
http://bgm.tv/user/332743
http://bgm.tv/user/332052
http://bgm.tv/user/332488
http://bgm.tv/user/333013
http://bgm.tv/user/332769
http://bgm.tv/user/334928
http://bgm.tv/user/334853
http://bgm.tv/user/334818
http://bgm.tv/user/334771
http://bgm.tv/user/334768
http://bgm.tv/user/334724
http://bgm.tv/user/324911
http://bgm.tv/user/324907
http://bgm.tv/user/324764
http://bgm.tv/user/324760
http://bgm.tv/user/324744
http://bgm.tv/user/319147
http://bgm.tv/user/320223
http://bgm.tv/user/320695
http://bgm.tv/user/320196
http://bgm.tv/user/319482
http://bgm.tv/user/319481
http://bgm.tv/user/319366
http://bgm.tv/user/311119
http://bgm.tv/user/311062
http://bgm.tv/user/307961
http://bgm.tv/user/307837
http://bgm.tv/user/307700
http://bgm.tv/user/307623
http://bgm.tv/user/307620
http://bgm.tv/user/307452
http://bgm.tv/user/307025
http://bgm.tv/user/306600
http://bgm.tv/user/306486
http://bgm.tv/user/306441
http://bgm.tv/user/306281
http://bgm.tv/user/305930
http://bgm.tv/user/305698
http://bgm.tv/user/305668
http://bgm.tv/user/305602
http://bgm.tv/user/305522
http://bgm.tv/user/305459
http://bgm.tv/user/305367
http://bgm.tv/user/305063
http://bgm.tv/user/304772
http://bgm.tv/user/304615
http://bgm.tv/user/304168
http://bgm.tv/user/303978
http://bgm.tv/user/303175
http://bgm.tv/user/302671
http://bgm.tv/user/302169
http://bgm.tv/user/301319
http://bgm.tv/user/300489
http://bgm.tv/user/299503
http://bgm.tv/user/299161
http://bgm.tv/user/298953
http://bgm.tv/user/298801
http://bgm.tv/user/298581
一些相对比较旧的帐号,挖一下
http://bgm.tv/user/174374
http://bgm.tv/user/295135
http://bgm.tv/user/250646
http://bgm.tv/user/232375
http://bgm.tv/user/211474
http://bgm.tv/user/113809
http://bgm.tv/user/42681
http://bgm.tv/user/238826
这几个可能是同一人
http://bgm.tv/user/115092
http://bgm.tv/user/115822
http://bgm.tv/user/115948
还有几个用户我不太能理解,帐号是一直在用的,但是这样的评分方式有什么意义?如果可能的话,还请现身说法
评分难道不是给自己看的吗?
@shuafende
@Friedrich
最后是站内吉祥物之一这个你们想保留的话我也没意见
京都是神
附链接http://bgm.tv/blog/270420

之前vxow大大把举报楼真爱楼给删了,补一个好了

基本都是些新注册、只用过一两次、没头像、昵称莫名其妙或别有用心、标记条目较少、没点过标签、分数集中在1和10的ID
http://bgm.tv/user/328780
http://bgm.tv/user/329955
http://bgm.tv/user/330625
http://bgm.tv/user/331247
http://bgm.tv/user/331270
http://bgm.tv/user/331278
http://bgm.tv/user/331281
http://bgm.tv/user/331280
http://bgm.tv/user/331290
http://bgm.tv/user/331299
http://bgm.tv/user/331303
http://bgm.tv/user/331465
http://bgm.tv/user/331624
http://bgm.tv/user/332935
http://bgm.tv/user/331862
http://bgm.tv/user/331249
http://bgm.tv/user/331640
http://bgm.tv/user/332743
http://bgm.tv/user/332052
http://bgm.tv/user/332488
http://bgm.tv/user/333013
http://bgm.tv/user/332769
http://bgm.tv/user/334928
http://bgm.tv/user/334853
http://bgm.tv/user/334818
http://bgm.tv/user/334771
http://bgm.tv/user/334768
http://bgm.tv/user/334724
http://bgm.tv/user/324911
http://bgm.tv/user/324907
http://bgm.tv/user/324764
http://bgm.tv/user/324760
http://bgm.tv/user/324744
http://bgm.tv/user/319147
http://bgm.tv/user/320223
http://bgm.tv/user/320695
http://bgm.tv/user/320196
http://bgm.tv/user/319482
http://bgm.tv/user/319481
http://bgm.tv/user/319366
http://bgm.tv/user/311119
http://bgm.tv/user/311062
http://bgm.tv/user/307961
http://bgm.tv/user/307837
http://bgm.tv/user/307700
http://bgm.tv/user/307623
http://bgm.tv/user/307620
http://bgm.tv/user/307452
http://bgm.tv/user/307025
http://bgm.tv/user/306600
http://bgm.tv/user/306486
http://bgm.tv/user/306441
http://bgm.tv/user/306281
http://bgm.tv/user/305930
http://bgm.tv/user/305698
http://bgm.tv/user/305668
http://bgm.tv/user/305602
http://bgm.tv/user/305522
http://bgm.tv/user/305459
http://bgm.tv/user/305367
http://bgm.tv/user/305063
http://bgm.tv/user/304772
http://bgm.tv/user/304615
http://bgm.tv/user/304168
http://bgm.tv/user/303978
http://bgm.tv/user/303175
http://bgm.tv/user/302671
http://bgm.tv/user/302169
http://bgm.tv/user/301319
http://bgm.tv/user/300489
http://bgm.tv/user/299503
http://bgm.tv/user/299161
http://bgm.tv/user/298953
http://bgm.tv/user/298801
http://bgm.tv/user/298581
一些相对比较旧的帐号,挖一下
http://bgm.tv/user/174374
http://bgm.tv/user/295135
http://bgm.tv/user/250646
http://bgm.tv/user/232375
http://bgm.tv/user/211474
http://bgm.tv/user/113809
http://bgm.tv/user/42681
http://bgm.tv/user/238826
这几个可能是同一人
http://bgm.tv/user/115092
http://bgm.tv/user/115822
http://bgm.tv/user/115948
还有几个用户我不太能理解,帐号是一直在用的,但是这样的评分方式有什么意义?如果可能的话,还请现身说法
评分难道不是给自己看的吗?
@shuafende
@Friedrich
最后是站内吉祥物之一这个你们想保留的话我也没意见

京都是神
附链接http://bgm.tv/blog/270420
http://bgm.tv/user/339588
http://bgm.tv/user/339736
http://bgm.tv/user/339937
http://bgm.tv/user/340092
http://bgm.tv/user/340282
http://bgm.tv/user/340493
http://bgm.tv/user/340755
http://bgm.tv/user/341133
http://bgm.tv/user/341308
http://bgm.tv/user/341648
http://bgm.tv/user/341869
http://bgm.tv/user/342072
http://bgm.tv/user/342475
http://bgm.tv/user/342677
http://bgm.tv/user/342904
http://bgm.tv/user/343193
http://bgm.tv/user/343478
http://bgm.tv/user/345468
http://bgm.tv/user/345700
http://bgm.tv/user/345804
封他四个账号,他又重开四个,上一层里那十八个号是因我之前疏忽而漏抓的,麻烦管理员来处理一下。
http://bgm.tv/user/346538
http://bgm.tv/user/346783
http://bgm.tv/user/347037
还是这一个人,起初我以为他又新开了十几个刷分号,继而发现原来14-1楼里十八个号至今依然存活。接连两次,四个账号被封那就重开四个,总之他铁了心要开马甲总计二十二个。
http://bgm.tv/anime/list/335858/collect
@Sai
http://bgm.tv/user/vvv
@Sai
你们慢慢玩,告辞~
https://bgm.tv/user/412154
另外刷分还有个特征就是短期内出现打分行为高度相同的多个号,比如下面这些:
https://bgm.tv/user/341648
https://bgm.tv/user/341488
https://bgm.tv/user/341308
https://bgm.tv/user/341133
https://bgm.tv/user/340755
https://bgm.tv/user/340493
https://bgm.tv/user/340282
https://bgm.tv/user/340092
https://bgm.tv/user/339937
https://bgm.tv/user/339736
https://bgm.tv/user/315571
https://bgm.tv/user/339588
最后@Sai
http://bgm.tv/user/414152
http://bgm.tv/user/413882
http://bgm.tv/user/413877
http://bgm.tv/user/413875
http://bgm.tv/user/414160
http://bgm.tv/user/413893
http://bgm.tv/user/414077
http://bgm.tv/user/414079
http://bgm.tv/user/414078
http://bgm.tv/user/414130
http://bgm.tv/user/414131
http://bgm.tv/user/414132
http://bgm.tv/user/414161
http://bgm.tv/user/413917
http://bgm.tv/user/413913
http://bgm.tv/user/414123
http://bgm.tv/user/414122
http://bgm.tv/user/414121
@Sai
在这个页面上搜一下就有了 hhh
#36-4 hhh
而且一十评分的话 估计也不止这一位 ...
没“过界”话 也就这样了 ~
http://bgm.tv/user/336093
http://bgm.tv/user/359328
http://bgm.tv/user/427422
http://bgm.tv/user/429872
http://bgm.tv/user/430942
http://bgm.tv/user/431281
http://bgm.tv/user/433244
https://tieba.baidu.com/p/6012480212
简介都一个样子
还有一个,应该也是同一个人
与前面两个是连着三天注册的,同样是一击脱离,高低分作品基本一致。
疑似大号
我去 还有
https://bgm.tv/user/468536
https://bgm.tv/user/457743
https://bgm.tv/user/466508
https://bgm.tv/user/467956
https://bgm.tv/user/455729
https://bgm.tv/user/465109
https://bgm.tv/user/457028
https://bgm.tv/user/461042
https://bgm.tv/user/458135
https://bgm.tv/user/475268
https://bgm.tv/user/462315
http://bgm.tv/user/455729
http://bgm.tv/user/457043
http://bgm.tv/user/460911
http://bgm.tv/user/500979
http://bgm.tv/user/456763
http://bgm.tv/user/457379
@Sai🖖🖖
国产作也是要小心“国产崛起”。
https://bgm.tv/user/5977
https://bgm.tv/user/58491
https://bgm.tv/user/77609
https://bgm.tv/user/241932
https://bgm.tv/user/304248
https://bgm.tv/user/335568
https://bgm.tv/user/384084
https://bgm.tv/user/396778
https://bgm.tv/user/416654
https://bgm.tv/user/424044
https://bgm.tv/user/437135
https://bgm.tv/user/442524
https://bgm.tv/user/460700
https://bgm.tv/user/464580
https://bgm.tv/user/461909
https://bgm.tv/user/487648
https://bgm.tv/user/496659
https://bgm.tv/user/500496
https://bgm.tv/user/502478
https://bgm.tv/user/wr2300
https://bgm.tv/user/suzumiyaharuhi1
https://bgm.tv/user/timeofsky
https://bgm.tv/user/nyaaar
https://bgm.tv/user/waynewu
有鱼
第三个看起来也像是活人还写日志的,是不是误伤了?
这么说吧,如果它足够活跃,你怎么判断它是小号还是“异己”的活人?可以去清除它吗?再退一步,如果我开了一个足够活跃的小号,有谁可以在对此不知情的情况下清除掉这个号吗?
即使它真的是一盘大棋(我觉得不是),要求清除这些“无法分辨"的账号这一心理需求也是病态的。
全看√
ps:web端用bbcode真麻烦
https://bgm.tv/user/515996
https://bgm.tv/user/516027
接
https://bgm.tv/user/436495
https://bgm.tv/user/462652
https://bgm.tv/user/545505
https://bgm.tv/user/537788
https://bgm.tv/user/477138
https://bgm.tv/user/380967
https://bgm.tv/user/541862
https://bgm.tv/user/533920
https://bgm.tv/user/539605
https://bgm.tv/user/539326
https://bgm.tv/user/537322
https://bgm.tv/user/535281
https://bgm.tv/user/436495
https://bgm.tv/user/462652
https://bgm.tv/user/545505
https://bgm.tv/user/537788
https://bgm.tv/user/477138
https://bgm.tv/user/380967
https://bgm.tv/user/541862
https://bgm.tv/user/533920
https://bgm.tv/user/539605
https://bgm.tv/user/539326
https://bgm.tv/user/537322
https://bgm.tv/user/535281
https://bgm.tv/user/436495
https://bgm.tv/user/462652
https://bgm.tv/user/545505
https://bgm.tv/user/537788
https://bgm.tv/user/477138
https://bgm.tv/user/380967
https://bgm.tv/user/541862
https://bgm.tv/user/533920
https://bgm.tv/user/539605
https://bgm.tv/user/539326
https://bgm.tv/user/537322
https://bgm.tv/user/535281
https://bgm.tv/user/436495
https://bgm.tv/user/462652
https://bgm.tv/user/545505
https://bgm.tv/user/537788
https://bgm.tv/user/477138
https://bgm.tv/user/380967
https://bgm.tv/user/541862
https://bgm.tv/user/533920
https://bgm.tv/user/539605
https://bgm.tv/user/539326
https://bgm.tv/user/537322
https://bgm.tv/user/535281
https://bgm.tv/user/436495
https://bgm.tv/user/462652
https://bgm.tv/user/545505
https://bgm.tv/user/537788
https://bgm.tv/user/477138
https://bgm.tv/user/380967
https://bgm.tv/user/541862
https://bgm.tv/user/533920
https://bgm.tv/user/539605
https://bgm.tv/user/539326
https://bgm.tv/user/537322
https://bgm.tv/user/535281
https://bgm.tv/user/436495
https://bgm.tv/user/462652
https://bgm.tv/user/545505
https://bgm.tv/user/537788
https://bgm.tv/user/477138
https://bgm.tv/user/380967
https://bgm.tv/user/541862
https://bgm.tv/user/533920
https://bgm.tv/user/539605
https://bgm.tv/user/539326
https://bgm.tv/user/537322
https://bgm.tv/user/535281
https://bgm.tv/user/436495
https://bgm.tv/user/462652
https://bgm.tv/user/545505
https://bgm.tv/user/537788
https://bgm.tv/user/477138
https://bgm.tv/user/380967
https://bgm.tv/user/541862
https://bgm.tv/user/533920
https://bgm.tv/user/539605
https://bgm.tv/user/539326
https://bgm.tv/user/537322
https://bgm.tv/user/535281
https://bgm.tv/user/436495
https://bgm.tv/user/462652
https://bgm.tv/user/545505
https://bgm.tv/user/537788
https://bgm.tv/user/477138
https://bgm.tv/user/380967
https://bgm.tv/user/541862
https://bgm.tv/user/533920
https://bgm.tv/user/539605
https://bgm.tv/user/539326
https://bgm.tv/user/537322
https://bgm.tv/user/535281
https://bgm.tv/user/436495
https://bgm.tv/user/462652
https://bgm.tv/user/545505
https://bgm.tv/user/537788
https://bgm.tv/user/477138
https://bgm.tv/user/380967
https://bgm.tv/user/541862
https://bgm.tv/user/533920
https://bgm.tv/user/539605
https://bgm.tv/user/539326
https://bgm.tv/user/537322
https://bgm.tv/user/535281
一小时内给两部相同的作品打出一分,恶意刷分石锤:
https://bgm.tv/user/531830
https://bgm.tv/user/531828
https://bgm.tv/user/irokitsune
https://bgm.tv/user/233273
https://bgm.tv/user/531820
打分行为呈高度相似性,刷分意图明显:
https://bgm.tv/user/515626
https://bgm.tv/user/507360
https://bgm.tv/user/502366
当然不能忘了这位万年不变的真爱海の御先
刷分不那么极端了学会分散了,有进步
https://bgm.tv/user/436495
https://bgm.tv/user/462652
https://bgm.tv/user/545505
https://bgm.tv/user/537788
https://bgm.tv/user/477138
https://bgm.tv/user/380967
https://bgm.tv/user/541862
https://bgm.tv/user/533920
https://bgm.tv/user/539605
https://bgm.tv/user/539326
https://bgm.tv/user/537322
https://bgm.tv/user/535281
4、5、6月份攻壳1+2季+剧场版1三部番合计的类似疑似刷分用户:
https://bgm.tv/user/541392
https://bgm.tv/user/539517
https://bgm.tv/user/536712
https://bgm.tv/user/533496
https://bgm.tv/user/546612
https://bgm.tv/user/281545
https://bgm.tv/user/545588
https://bgm.tv/user/124786
https://bgm.tv/user/543086
https://bgm.tv/user/538772
4、5、6月份EVA TV+旧剧场二部番合计的类似疑似刷分用户:
https://bgm.tv/user/546005
https://bgm.tv/user/543893
https://bgm.tv/user/543113
https://bgm.tv/user/541920
https://bgm.tv/user/539434
https://bgm.tv/user/539275
https://bgm.tv/user/545059
https://bgm.tv/user/538299
4、5、6月份追忆篇的类似疑似刷分用户:
https://bgm.tv/user/544147
https://bgm.tv/user/531493
http://bgm.tv/user/473261
@Sai🖖🖖
http://bgm.tv/user/263905
http://bgm.tv/user/550456
@Sai🖖
http://bgm.tv/user/551588
@Sai🖖
只是在列表里面看见一个奇怪的例外 就拉出来吐槽一下这样的 hhh
https://bgm.tv/user/605561
特征同上。
@Sai🖖
https://bgm.tv/user/605897
https://bgm.tv/user/605959
特征同上
@Sai🖖
还是再说一下吧,此人刷分意图明显(高分条目重合度极高,行为高度相似),但由于其标记条目多,手段高明,如主页标记其他人的网站帐号伪装真人、定期标记等等。使得常人难以发现这类操作多条目多的帐号的真实意图。不排除有组织作案,程序作案的嫌异,而本人是纯靠手动查找,而结果又非常荒唐离谱,但又非常真实。
bangumi本身极度缺乏监管,这些人/组织稍用技俩就能瞒过用户和清分,虽然说上面大量刷分都得到了处理,本人的列举仔细调查表明也明显是个人操控,但我也不知上面这些煞废苦心伪装的帐号能否及时得到最公正的处理,让bangumi生态变得健康,整体环境能变得越来越好。
而不是因缺乏证据石沉大海。
网站的公正和谐是每一位心地善良班友的愿望,一人查号举报耗时耗力,所以希望有心人能一起帮助,一起监督。
https://bgm.tv/user/483546
@Sai🖖
打分倾向相似且都没有标签,一击脱离
https://bgm.tv/user/657212
https://bgm.tv/user/656937
还有这三位 @Sai🖖
同一人注册的小号,注册和活跃时间高度重合,对相同动画的打分基本一样
https://bgm.tv/user/606017
https://bgm.tv/user/682890
https://bgm.tv/user/682656
追加三个
@Sai🖖
[来自Bangumi for android] 获取
这人狂刷回复
@Sai🖖
https://bgm.tv/user/714936
与上面一模一样的情况,昵称都是一样的
@Sai🖖🖖
https://bgm.tv/blog/312236
看起来像串子炒作人
https://bgm.tv/user/510308
https://bgm.tv/user/326105
https://bgm.tv/user/712573
https://bgm.tv/user/707615
https://bgm.tv/user/705793
https://bgm.tv/user/552315
https://bgm.tv/user/713065
https://bgm.tv/user/717091
https://bgm.tv/user/666918
https://bgm.tv/user/676516
https://bgm.tv/user/717949
https://bgm.tv/user/420879
https://bgm.tv/user/719570
https://bgm.tv/user/719575
https://bgm.tv/user/590282
https://bgm.tv/user/714175
https://bgm.tv/user/710564
https://bgm.tv/user/716934
https://bgm.tv/user/716786
像我发的上面那些也是季经帖了,一击即退党涌入了好多,而且我看到好多人注册了一点动静没有,估计会突然诈尸上线刷分
等她有时间看看会不会搞点吧,不过感觉定期清分也挺好的,省事
我也给老板提过加注册限制的建议,但老板貌似没这个想法。其实我觉得类似贴吧那种经验制是最好的,登录、动态、收藏条目都会加经验,升到一定等级之后才开放评分功能。
@Sai🖖
动漫老师和动漫学生明显不是一个人