Indie Spirits　／　独立精神 » 讨论
为什么Steam游戏评论页面的热评经常是黄梗和一堆脏话问候诅咒游戏公司，现在游戏玩家的素质已经这么差了吗？

steam毕竟是卖游戏的地方，大概是当成和外卖平台一样了，没有形成社区意识

1.  评论可能往往不是玩家发的
2.  简中语境不存在「自治」概念，因而不能理解「社区」
3.  作为全世界互联网黑产最发达的地区之一，任何东西都能交易
4.  作为全世界政治压力最大的地区之一，能在任何可留存文字的地方遭到（或内或外的）政治性攻击/报复

所以即便无关玩家素质，一样有足够多的因素能导致这些垃圾评论泛滥，然后毫无新意地地掉入每个烂掉的平台都走过的比烂循环最终无可救药

【 反馈草稿 】

你好，我是一位普通玩家，玩了很多年游戏的玩家，我很喜欢电子游戏，可能和您一样。

我想提出一点建议——


现在 Steam 的游戏评论页面（至少中文评论区域），有许多热评都是各种和游戏本身无关的黄色梗，和恶意骂游戏制作公司、游戏制作人的评论

在我的印象中，游戏评论应该是表达自己对游戏的真实感受、看法、建议的，而不是一股脑的自我发泄，恶心看到这个评论的其他玩家；
我知道可能有一些玩家对这种发泄评论有共鸣，但这种评论不应该成为一种风气，不是吗？

因为你我都知道这种评论不可能让游戏开发变得更好，只会让游戏圈子乌烟瘴气被外部的人瞧不起，而且陷入没有帮助的恶性循环，同时我认为这种脏话评论也会伤害到真正喜欢这款游戏的人和游戏开发者；说到底，这就是一款电子游戏（不可能每一款游戏都会成为艺术品，有的就只是普通商品），游戏制作人到底做了什么伤天害理的事要被 问候全家、失去亲人、成为智障、还要吃X、被XX？

当然我们无法决定由什么样的人群购买游玩电子游戏，但至少我们可以规范一下言论，在每一位玩家开始评论前进行告知评论告知：比如平台欢迎什么样有价值的评论，不建议、甚至不允许怎样的恶意评论

在中国有一句话叫“劣币驱逐良币”，也就是西方所说的“格雷欣现象（Gresham's Law）”，可以简单理解“坏的”终将会排挤走“好的”最后让这个市场变得很糟糕，为此我不希望游戏圈子里最后全变成骂来骂去的一群负能量玩家，让这个世界更加封闭与割裂。

希望你们能做出一点改变，通过平台规则与引导提示管理一下游戏评论区域，感谢。


—— 来自一位真诚的游戏玩家 “w2jmoe”

此致 敬礼，感谢阅读　2023年11月28日10:42:30



———————————————————— Translated from ChatGPT to English

Hello, I am an ordinary gamer who has been playing games for many years, much like yourself. I really enjoy electronic games.

I would like to make a suggestion—

Currently, on the game review pages of Steam (at least in the Chinese comment section), many popular reviews consist of various unrelated adult jokes and malicious comments towards game development companies and game producers.

In my opinion, game reviews should be a genuine expression of one's feelings, opinions, and suggestions about the game, rather than a mindless venting of frustration. It's disheartening to see other players disgusted by these comments. I understand that some players may resonate with such venting, but shouldn't this kind of commentary be discouraged?

Because, as we both know, such comments are unlikely to make game development better; they only serve to tarnish the gaming community's reputation and contribute to an unhelpful vicious cycle. Moreover, I believe that these vulgar comments can also harm those who genuinely love the game and the game developers. After all, it's just a video game (not every game can be considered a work of art; some are just ordinary products). What could game developers possibly have done to deserve insults targeting their families, loss of loved ones, accusations of mental disabilities, or other offensive remarks?

Of course, we cannot control who purchases and plays electronic games, but we can at least regulate speech. Before each player starts commenting, there could be a notification about what kind of comments the platform welcomes, discourages, or even disallows, especially malicious ones.

In China, there is a saying, "劣币驱逐良币," which is akin to the Western concept of "Gresham's Law." It can be simply understood as "bad money driving out good," ultimately making the market very unpleasant. Therefore, I do not wish for the gaming community to devolve into a group of players constantly exchanging negative comments, making the world more closed and divided.

I hope you can make some changes by managing the game review section through platform rules and guidance prompts. Thank you.

— A sincere gamer, "w2jmoe"

Best regards, and thank you for reading. November 28, 2023, 10:42:30